Beyond Predictable Neutrals: The Burnished Authority of Sherwin-Williams Tarnished Treasure (SW 9118)

For homeowners looking to step away from predictable neutrals before the hosting season begins, Sherwin-Williams Tarnished Treasure (SW 9118) offers a remarkably grounded, welcoming alternative. It is an earthen, aged brass tone that feels right at home in the late-autumn and early-winter calendar. Instead of fighting the amber glow of your evening lamps and dining fixtures, it leans right into it, wrapping a room in warmth the moment dusk settles over Hendricks County.

To understand how a color like this behaves on your walls, it helps to look at its Light Reflectance Value, or LRV. On a scale from zero to one hundred, Tarnished Treasure sits at an LRV of 24. In plain English, this means it is a medium-deep shade that absorbs a good deal of light rather than bouncing it back into the room. It brings genuine depth and coziness without making a space feel like a dark cave.

Let's explore a visual walkthrough of how this shade functions in a representative Mid-Century Modern layout in Brownsburg, where organic geometries, warm woods, and high clerestory windows define the architecture. In a primary bedroom or a conversation-focused living room, Tarnished Treasure acts as an immediate anchor. When paired with rich walnut paneling, teak flooring, and molded plywood furniture, a flat or matte finish on the walls smooths out surface imperfections and gives the paint a velvety, suede-like appearance that invites you to sit down and stay awhile.

Save

Reading the Undertones From Late-Autumn Daylight to Evening Hosting

Every complex paint color has a hidden personality that comes out depending on the time of day, and Tarnished Treasure is driven by a blend of gold, ochre, and muted olive undertones. Because it has that earthen olive base, it never veers into the territory of a bright, sunny yellow or a brassy mustard.

During the day, when soft, even natural daylight filters through high windows looking out onto bare late-autumn trees and frost-touched Indiana lawns, the olive and raw ochre notes step forward. The color reads like dry, cured tobacco leaf or vintage brass hardware. However, when 5:00 PM hits and you flip on your warm recessed lights or dim the dining room chandelier for guests, the gold undertone wakes up. Under amber evening bulbs, the walls take on a burnished, honeyed richness that flatters wood furniture and makes a large living or dining area feel instantly intimate.

Save

Framing the Architecture with Crisp Trim and Quiet Transitions

When you put a rich, gold-infused shade with an LRV of 24 on your walls, you cannot pair it with a stark, icy white on the trim—doing so creates a harsh, jarring outline that cheapens the look of both colors. Instead, a shade with this much warmth needs a soft, creamy partner to frame the architecture. Applying Sherwin-Williams Alabaster (SW 7008) in a satin or semi-gloss sheen along the baseboards, window casings, and door frames gives you a clean, classic contrast that still feels relaxed. Alabaster has just enough warmth in its own base to sit comfortably next to Tarnished Treasure while still looking decidedly crisp and clean against solid wood floors.

Save

Of course, most homes have sightlines that carry your eye from the main living or dining area into hallways, foyers, and open kitchens. If you want to give the eye a resting place in those connecting spaces without losing the organic, nature-inspired feel of the home, Sherwin-Williams Rare Gray (SW 6199) is an ideal companion. Rare Gray is a soft, grounded neutral with a subtle green-gray cast. When you look through a doorway framed in Alabaster from a dining room painted in Tarnished Treasure, Rare Gray in the adjoining foyer picks up on those quiet olive undertones, creating a smooth, effortless flow from room to room.

Grounding Kitchens, Built-Ins, and Vanities with Deep Plum

The months leading up to the holidays are peak season for refinishing dated kitchen cabinets, dining room buffets, and bathroom vanities. If you have fifteen- or twenty-year-old cabinetry that has lost its luster, paint is the most reliable way to give that woodwork a completely custom architectural presence before family arrives.

While many homeowners automatically reach for navy blue or charcoal for their islands and built-ins, pairing Tarnished Treasure with Benjamin Moore Shadow (2117-30) creates a far more memorable, designer-level combination. Shadow is a deep, dusty amethyst-plum that sits opposite gold and ochre on the color wheel. In a Mid-Century Modern kitchen or dining space where adjoining walls carry Tarnished Treasure or Rare Gray, spraying the cabinetry or a central island in Benjamin Moore Shadow using a durable urethane alkyd enamel in a satin finish grounds the entire room. Against brushed brass hardware and warm walnut accents, this deep plum reads like a sophisticated neutral with a rich, velvety soul under warm evening lighting.

Save

This same combination works wonders in smaller spaces like a guest powder room or a primary bathroom. Painting the walls in Tarnished Treasure, finishing the trim in Alabaster, and coating a freestanding walnut-and-painted vanity in Benjamin Moore Shadow turns a functional washroom into a tailored space that guests will remember long after Thanksgiving dessert is served.

Save

When you step outside the comfort zone of standard grays and off-whites, you give your woodwork, lighting, and furniture a backdrop that actually supports them. Tarnished Treasure brings an honest, burnished warmth that makes a house feel settled and ready for company, no matter how early the winter sun goes down.

After

Before

AI Design Tool

Visualize Your Space with Color Studio AI

Planning a project? Skip the paint chip guesswork. Use our Color Studio AI to instantly visualize these paint colors on your own walls, or take advantage of our aligned contractor pricing matching current Sherwin-Williams retail promotions.

Try Color Studio AI →

Continue Exploring

Related Color & Design Studies

All Articles →

Warm Gray and Muted Green Converge in the Quiet Depth of Sherwin-Williams Ellsworth (SW 7650)

Read Study →

Velvety Shadows and Intimate Evening Dining Wrapped in Benjamin Moore Secret AF-710

Read Study →

Crisp Trim and Warm Timber Find Their Quiet Counterpart in Sherwin-Williams Nonchalant White SW 6161

Read Study →